cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
  • 306 Views

Inode not showing when following guided excercise

On the 9.3 version of the RH courseware on page 22 (ch03s08) bullet point 2.3; when you execute "ls -l files/target.file links/file.hardlink" the inode number is not shown. Instead using "ls -li files/target.file links/file.hardlink" it is.

Labels (1)
Tags (4)
4 Replies
Jason_R_Preston
Flight Engineer
Flight Engineer
  • 307 Views

Good catch. You are correct. You need to use "ls -li" to see the inode information, but the instructions tell you to use "ls -l" which does NOT show the inode information.

Andrew
Flight Engineer
Flight Engineer
  • 281 Views

The instructions also do not call the inode to the attention of the learner as the definitive way to demonstrate mastery of the hard link concept. Showing the number of hard links, as noted, is certainly a valid and important concept, but only demonstrates that there are hard links, and that they increment on each file when a new link is created, Demonstrating that they are the same file (espeically after-the-fact of its having been created) requires revelaing the inode and this should, in my opinion, be added here to both the shown command and the explanatory verbiage. I add it when leading learners through this exercise, but for learners without a live instructor, adding it would be beneficial.

@trialestes great callout!

Tags (4)
Chetan_Tiwary_
Community Manager
Community Manager
  • 242 Views

@trialestes @Andrew @Jason_R_Preston Thanks for your feedback . Let me forward it to the respective course developers for reviewing it. 

Tags (4)
Chetan_Tiwary_
Community Manager
Community Manager
  • 203 Views

I got to know that this issue was addressed in the latest course release RH124v10. 

https://rol.redhat.com/rol/app/courses/rh124-10.0/pages/ch07s04 

Tags (4)
Join the discussion
You must log in to join this conversation.