compreview-review grade script failed to check a role binding requirement

[ltourreau1]

On the comprehensive review lab
It is requested to create a local binding for the presenter group to the admin cluster role with the workshop name.
If you do that, the grade script failed because it checks if the local bind is created to admin cluster for the do280-presenter user (instead of presenter group) with the workshop name:

FAIL: Validating do280-presenter user has the admin role in the do280 project
          - The step has failed
          - Binds to a Group instead of User
          - Binds to presenters instead of do280-presenter

[Chetan_Tiwary_ · Accepted solution]

Hello @ltourreau1 !

Thanks for reaching out!

I was able to validate the issue you have mentioned here and I have reported this to the appropriate internal forum for further investigation & resolution. Thank you for your feedback !

[Jcalvod]

I am not sure that really be an issue, because i had this error in the past and i have find the problem was in my interpretation of what RedHat request us... They explicitly says :

As the do280-support user, you must create the do280-attendees group with the do280-attendee user, and assign the edit cluster role to the do280-attendees group.

Really "edit" is a cluster role because of this reason they request us "assign the edit cluster role" but cluster roles can be used as a cluster level role or as a project level role. If you use it as a project level that is the manner that Red Hat is requesting us in the exercise yo need to assign it to the group as a simply role not "cluster role manner". Doing this assignation to the group you will see that next when you validate the result this point will be OK . This is the way to interprete this request in this exercise.

I desire to have helped you!